How to Choose the Right Siding Contractor in New York: A Homeowner’s Guide
June 11, 2025

When it’s time to refresh or repair your home’s exterior, few upgrades are as impactful as new siding. But finding the right siding contractor—especially in a place as unique and weather-challenged as New York—can make all the difference between a project that adds lasting value and one that quickly turns into a costly regret.



At Gibraltar Home Improvements, we’ve spent over 40 years helping homeowners across Long Island, Queens, and Brooklyn make smart, informed decisions about siding installation. This guide walks you through everything you need to know before hiring a siding contractor—so you can feel confident you’re getting the best value, quality, and results.

Why Siding Isn’t Just Cosmetic


When most people think about siding, they think about curb appeal—and that’s not wrong. New siding can absolutely transform the look of your home. But more importantly, siding plays a critical functional role in protecting your property. It’s your home’s first line of defense against New York’s unpredictable weather—freezing winters, humid summers, high winds, salt air, and more.


Old or failing siding can lead to a wide range of structural problems:


  • Water intrusion that causes mold, rot, and mildew
  • Pest infestations through gaps or cracks
  • Energy inefficiency from poor insulation or loose panels
  • Exterior decay that lowers property value and raises maintenance costs


A professionally installed siding system helps to seal and insulate your home, reduce your energy bills, and extend the overall lifespan of your structure. And when installed by experts like the team at Gibraltar Home Improvements, it also boosts your property’s resale value with a polished, modern exterior.


The Biggest Mistakes Homeowners Make When Hiring a Siding Contractor


Let’s face it—homeowners don’t shop for siding contractors every day. As a result, many people end up making avoidable mistakes. Here are a few of the most common:


1. Choosing a General Contractor Instead of a Siding Specialist

General contractors may know their way around multiple trades, but siding isn’t a side job—it’s a precision craft. At Gibraltar, we focus exclusively on exterior improvements, including siding, and we’ve fine-tuned our process to deliver consistently strong results.


2. Focusing Only on Price

Budget matters, but going with the lowest quote often leads to subpar materials, rushed labor, and costly fixes down the road. Gibraltar offers fair, transparent pricing—without sacrificing quality or cutting corners.


3. Overlooking Credentials

Too often, homeowners fail to verify that a contractor is properly licensed, bonded, and insured. Gibraltar meets all legal requirements and carries additional protections to ensure your project is done right.


4. Ignoring Local Experience

Building codes, climate, and architectural style vary from neighborhood to neighborhood. Our deep familiarity with Long Island, Queens, and Brooklyn homes means we understand exactly what each property needs.


Avoiding these missteps helps you get the most from your investment—and it starts with choosing a seasoned expert like Gibraltar Home Improvements.


What to Look for in a Siding Contractor


Finding a reliable siding contractor doesn’t have to be a guessing game. Here are five key traits to prioritize:


✅ Licensing & Insurance

Always choose a contractor who is licensed, bonded, and insured. This protects you in case of accidents, damage, or disputes. Gibraltar meets all local and state requirements—and then some.


✅ Specialization in Siding

A jack-of-all-trades is rarely a master of one. Gibraltar is a dedicated siding contractor, which means every member of our team is experienced with siding products, techniques, and installation practices.


✅ Material Expertise

The right siding material can vary based on your budget, climate, and personal preferences. We install vinyl, fiber cement, and engineered wood siding, and we help you select the best fit for your home’s needs.


✅ Proven Local Work

Ask for before-and-after photos. Check out reviews. At Gibraltar, we’ve worked on thousands of homes across the New York metro area—and we’re proud of the reputation we’ve built over four decades.


✅ Clear Communication

You should never be left in the dark about costs, schedules, or materials. We provide detailed estimates, free consultations, and ongoing project updates—so you always know what to expect.


Working with Gibraltar Home Improvements means you get a team that checks every box—and then some.


The Siding Installation Process Explained


A successful siding project is about more than slapping panels on your house. At Gibraltar, we follow a comprehensive, start-to-finish process designed for quality, efficiency, and long-term performance.


Step 1: Free In-Home Consultation

We visit your property to inspect your current siding and evaluate any structural issues. We also take the time to understand your goals, style preferences, and budget.


Step 2: Design and Material Selection

Our team walks you through siding options—color, texture, style, material—helping you choose a product that enhances your home’s character while offering durability and low maintenance.


Step 3: Detailed Estimate

We provide a clear, itemized quote with no hidden fees. We believe in transparency from day one.


Step 4: Removal of Old Siding

We carefully remove your existing siding and responsibly dispose of all materials, ensuring no mess is left behind.


Step 5: Prep and Installation

We prepare the exterior walls, install weatherproofing and insulation (if needed), and apply the new siding using time-tested techniques and tools.


Step 6: Final Inspection

Once complete, we walk the property with you to ensure every detail meets our high standards—and yours.


When you choose Gibraltar Home Improvements, you’re choosing a full-service team committed to precision, professionalism, and protection.


Costs & Financing Options for Siding


Siding is an investment—and one that pays off in long-term value. But how much should you expect to spend?


Factors That Impact Siding Costs:

  • Size and layout of your home
  • Type of siding selected
  • Removal and disposal of old materials
  • Prep work and insulation upgrades


Unlike some contractors, Gibraltar doesn’t believe in vague ballparks. We provide free, detailed estimates that break down all costs—so you know exactly what you’re paying for.


Flexible Financing

We also offer third-party financing options to help make your project more affordable. Whether you want to spread payments over time or take advantage of promotional offers, we’ll work with you to find the right solution.


Start by requesting your free estimate today—no obligation, just clear answers.


Why Local Expertise Matters in New York


Working with a contractor who understands your neighborhood isn’t just convenient—it’s essential.


New York-Specific Considerations:

  • Weatherproofing against coastal conditions and winter storms
  • Compliance with local building codes and HOA standards
  • Familiarity with diverse architectural styles from Brooklyn brownstones to Long Island colonials


At Gibraltar Home Improvements, we’ve seen it all—and we tailor every siding project to match both the aesthetic and functional needs of New York homes. It’s why homeowners across Long Island, Queens, and Brooklyn continue to choose us as their go-to siding contractor.


Long-Term Benefits of Choosing the Right Contractor


Getting new siding is about more than just updating your home—it’s about investing in its future.


Here’s what you can expect when you choose Gibraltar:

  • Lower utility bills thanks to energy-efficient siding and insulation
  • Minimal maintenance, with materials that resist rot, warping, and weather
  • Higher resale value, especially with modern, well-installed siding
  • Stronger protection from moisture, pests, and UV exposure
  • Peace of mind, with warranties and a reputation built on trust


Our clients don’t just get siding—they get long-term value, beautiful results, and dependable support from a company that’s been around since 1979.


Final Thoughts & Call to Action


Choosing a siding contractor shouldn’t be a leap of faith. You deserve a partner who brings experience, integrity, and proven results to your home improvement project.


With over four decades of service, thousands of successful installations, and a team that treats your home like their own, Gibraltar Home Improvements is ready to help you upgrade your exterior—on time, on budget, and with lasting quality.


Don’t settle for generalists or gimmicks. Trust the siding contractor that New York homeowners have relied on since 1979.


👉 Click here to schedule your free estimate with Gibraltar Home Improvements and take the first step toward transforming your home’s exterior.

EZ Switch

Gibraltar Home Improvements

Home Improvements. Gibraltar is your Long Island based full service home remodeling company. Since 1979 our focus has been helping homeowners remodel and renovate their homes.

Leave A Comment

Search Post

Recent Posts

A man and a woman are standing in front of a house under construction.
June 11, 2025
See what a professional siding contractor can do for your home. Gibraltar Home Improvements delivers full siding transformations across NYC and Long Island. Free estimates available.
A bathroom with a sink , mirror and shower.
April 23, 2025
Outdated bathroom? Poor lighting, storage issues, or water damage? See how Gibraltar’s expert bathroom remodeling services solve these problems with smart, stylish upgrades.
A wooden staircase with blue carpeted steps and a wooden railing.
April 23, 2025
Upgrade your home smartly with alternating tread stairs from Gibraltar—safe, stylish, and space-saving for attics, basements, and lofts.
A bathroom with a bathtub , toilet , sink and walk in shower.
April 23, 2025
Transform your bathroom with Gibraltar Home Improvements—expert modern remodeling that adds comfort, style, and value to your Long Island home.
A wooden alternating tread staircase with a wooden railing in a narrow room.
April 23, 2025
Discover how alternating tread stairs can enhance your home's functionality. Expert installation by Gibraltar Home Improvements in Long Island, Queens, and Brooklyn.​
A close up of a drain on a tiled floor in a bathroom. - black mold in shower
March 13, 2025
Struggling with black mold in your shower? DIY cleaning won’t solve it permanently. Gibraltar Home Improvements offers professional mold removal & bathroom remodeling. Get a free estimate today!
A neon sign on a brick wall that says man cave - basement man cave ideas
March 13, 2025
Looking for the best basement man cave ideas? Transform your basement into the ultimate retreat with Gibraltar Home Improvements. Free estimates available!
View All Recent Posts ➜

Share This Article